Ok, so I'm sure everyone else has there own opinions on podcasting in general, and podcasting tools, and it's no surprise I'm also one of them...
Anyway, I eagerly downloaded the new iTunes and iPod updates and gave this beast a whirl - WOW - ok, its nice. VERY nice. The interface looks clean, but...
- How the hell do I add a new podcast? Why, simply drag the URL from a browser to the app. Thats all well and good, but it would also be nice to have a simple "add a URL" entry box...
- How do I set a proxy? Ok, so we have fibre in the office capable of getting a nice 100kb/s transfers, the only problem is that when I do that no one else has ANY bandwidth, and Zach the admin nazi gets annoyed. For this reason I have my self a rate limited squid proxy, iTunes - how the hell do I use this? (After some initial annoyance, I set the proxy in Internet Explorer and bingo - iTunes will use this setting/proxy).
- There doesn't seem to be any options for automatic ID3 rewriting, or automated classification of a "podcast", problem due to the fact that there completely separate in the user interface - in both iTunes and the iPod. In fact, there so separate that my live bookmarks don't show them up, even thou the genres match.
- That leads me to this pet hate, the iPod has a new "podcasts" menu which list each different show, allowing me to drill down to each episode; but unlike the normal song/artist/album browser, theres no "all" option. So I can't just say "give me a playlist of all podcasts, at random". This could be a bit annoying...
All in all its looking nice, but iTunes doesn't exactly have the upgrade cycle of an open source app, so I don't think I'll be seeing any of these pet peeves go away anytime soon, nor do I know of any valid email address to submit these problems to ( or if anyone would answer if I did).
Still, my hat goes off to Apple for what they've given, it'll make getting podfolk into podcasting so much easier.
Update: Ryan Ozawa has started an
iTunes Podcasting Wiki page to track its quirks...
tags: rss apple podcasting ipod itunes
links: digg this del.icio.us technorati reddit